Phew, what a month it’s been, right? Time for eShop Selects, and let me tell you, it’s a wild ride. As we gear up for the holiday season, we’re practically drowning in games, especially with two of the biggest indies of the year dropping within weeks of each other. And let’s not forget the Nintendo Direct that showered us with even more titles for both Switch 1 and 2. Who needs free time when there are so many games to play, am I right?
Let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of how this all works: the Nintendo Life writers and contributors get together to vote for their top three eShop exclusives for the month. These games have been reviewed by the team, and based on those reviews, we assign scores from 1 to 3, with 1 being the highest. The numbers are tallied up, and voila, we have our final top three picks for the month. So, without further ado, let’s see what September’s best eShop games have in store for us.
First off, let’s give a shoutout to some honorable mentions that deserve some love. We’ve got Adventure of Samsara, Dead Reset, Gloomy Eyes, and Strange Antiquities, all scoring 7/10 or above. These gems may not have made it to the top three, but they’re definitely worth checking out if you’re looking for some new games to dive into. Now, onto the winners!
In third place, we have Earthion, a shmup that’s been making waves this year. With simple gameplay mechanics and challenging levels, this game is a blast to play. It finally landed on Switch in September 2025 and snagged a solid 8/10 rating from us. Moving on to second place, we have Hades II, a sequel that’s been highly anticipated. With new boons, weapons, and characters, this game offers endless replayability. It scored a well-deserved 9/10, just falling short of the top spot due to its weaker storyline, in my humble opinion.
And now, drumroll, please… the first-place title goes to Hollow Knight: Silksong! This game has been a topic of discussion due to its difficulty and size, but there’s no denying its brilliance. With expanded gameplay elements, tough enemies, and new challenges, Silksong is a must-play for those up for the challenge. It received a perfect 10/10 from us and rightfully claims the crown as our eShop Selects winner for September 2025. So, what are you waiting for? Dive into these games and let us know your thoughts in the comments below. Happy gaming!
