Dungeons & Dragons 2024 Player Handbook Review: A Familiar Yet Disappointing Upgrade
Dungeons & Dragons enthusiasts have been eagerly anticipating the release of the new “D&D 2024 ruleset” from Wizards of the Coast. After spending some time delving into the details of the latest edition, it’s clear that this new iteration is an evolution of the beloved D&D 5e system. While there are some improvements and adjustments, the overall feeling is that this upgrade falls short of delivering something truly groundbreaking.
Touch-ups & Tune-ups
Several core systems have been tweaked in the D&D 2024 ruleset to enhance gameplay. For example, the confusing “Surprised” condition has been simplified to give enemies disadvantage on their initiative rolls if they are caught off guard. Exhaustion mechanics have also been streamlined to provide a scaling penalty to D20 tests and movement speed. While these changes make the game more rules-lite, some adjustments, like the new grappling rules, may leave players feeling underwhelmed.
Character & Classes
Creating characters in D&D 2024 remains a familiar process, with some specific changes to races now being referred to as species and ability scores tied to backgrounds. Backgrounds now come with a free starting feat, adding a new dimension to character customization. Additionally, new classes like the College of Dance Bard offer fresh gameplay options for players to explore.
Feats are no longer optional rulesets and have been rebalanced to offer more variety and strategic choices for players. Spells have also undergone balancing adjustments, with some cantrips receiving boosts in damage and effectiveness. The introduction of Mastery Properties for weapons adds another layer of customization and depth to character builds.
Complaints & Contrarianisms
Despite the improvements in the D&D 2024 ruleset, there are still some lingering issues that may disappoint long-time players. The action economy continues to dominate gameplay, with limited options for players who are unable to perform their main actions. The lack of guidance for players in creating their own stories remains a challenge, with the alignment system taking center stage over character development.
The game’s failure to provide tools for players to build meaningful connections within their party and engage in collaborative storytelling is a missed opportunity. While some changes, like the three-action system in Pathfinder 2e, could have been bold additions, Wizards of the Coast opted for a more conservative approach with D&D 2024.
Looking Ahead
As the tabletop RPG landscape continues to evolve, D&D 2024 represents a missed opportunity for Wizards of the Coast to push the boundaries of traditional gameplay. While the new ruleset offers some enhancements and refinements, it ultimately falls short of delivering a truly innovative experience for players.
In conclusion, D&D 2024 may appeal to fans of the 5e system who are looking for a slightly improved version of the game. However, for those seeking a more revolutionary and transformative tabletop RPG experience, the latest edition may leave them wanting more. As the TTRPG genre continues to expand and diversify, it will be interesting to see how Wizards of the Coast responds to the evolving needs and expectations of players in the future.
